Yesterday, 11/11, was Veteran’s Day, but I’ve already
blogged about World War I, the global conflict which ended on that day in
1918. And recently I watched Matthew
McConaughey’s relatively recent film, “The Beach Bum”, though I’m pairing that
up with the “The Big Lebowski” spinoff film, “The Jesus Rolls”, on its way from
Netflix. As it is, I recently finished
watching season 4 of The Crown, the Netflix series about Queen Elizabeth
II. So I’ll comment about that.
The United Kingdom (UK = “Great Britain (England, Wales
& Scotland) + Northern Ireland”) is a constitutional monarchy. Nominally it has a King or Queen, plus
various princes and princesses, but “supreme executive authority” does indeed
derive from a “mandate from the masses”, so the real chief executive of the
country is the Prime Minister, who is the head of whichever political party holds
a majority in the House of Commons. Right
now that’s Boris Johnson, with the comically bad haircut – though it still
beats Marc Davis, the owner of the Las Vegas Raiders.
Anyhow. The current
royal family dates back to George I (1714-1727), the first king of the
House of Hanover. He is followed by George
II (1727-1760), George III (1760-1820) (king during the American
Revolution), George IV (1820-1830) (portrayed by Hugh Laurie in “The Black
Adder”), William IV (1830-1837), Queen Victoria (1837-1901)
(played by Jenna Coleman in the three season PBS series), Edward VII
(1901-1910), George V (1910-1936), Edward VIII (1936-1936) (abdicated
to marry Wallis Simpson (no, no relation to Homer), lived in the Bois de Boulogne
outside Paris), George VI (1936-52), and now Queen Elizabeth II (1952-present).
Note that Edward VIII did not have any
children with Wallis.
George VI was Edward VIII’s younger brother. As such, he would have been expecting Edward
VIII to take over as king from their father, George V, when he died, and Edward
VIII’s children to inherit the throne after that. E8’s abdication took G6 by surprise, he had
no expectation or preparation for it. He’s
famously portrayed by Colin Firth in “The King’s Speech”. In this series he’s played by Richard “Camelot”
Harris’ son Jared, who these days is in “Foundation” (on Apple TV+). Speaking of "The King's Speech", two actors from "The Crown" appear in that film, in different roles: Helena Bonham Carter plays Queen Elizabeth herself, and Derek Jacobi plays the Archbishop of York.
The Crown starts off with G6 as King and Elizabeth and her
younger sister Margaret as young girls.
They were old enough to experience World War II, and Elizabeth had to
have a fairly quick training program to prepare her to be queen, as G6 smoked
heavily and was in poor health, not expected to have the kind of long reign
Queen Victoria had – and which E2 has now surpassed. Claire Foy plays Elizabeth first as princess
then as queen for the first two seasons, Matt Smith (of Dr. Who) plays Prince
Philip in the first two seasons.
Who’s who?
Well, first is Princess/Queen Elizabeth (S1/2: Claire
Foy; S3/4 Olivia Colman). Easily the
star of the show. She is conscientious
about being a good Queen and knows her proper position relative to whoever
happens to be Prime Minister at the time.
She also has to manage her younger sister Margaret, somewhat of a loose
cannon, her relationship with Prince Philip, and later her sons Charles, Andrew
and Edward, and daughter Anne. Periodically the Prime Minister – mostly Harold
Wilson – comes to ask her for advice.
Later, the PM is none other than Margaret Thatcher, so she finally has a
female PM to face off against. Thatcher
is played by “X Files” veteran Gillian Anderson.
Prince Philip (S1/2
Matt Smith; S3/4 Tobias Menzies) is the Queen’s Consort. He’s her husband but somehow isn’t King despite
being the husband of a Queen (apparently he was asked about this countless
times). I found the Matt Smith version to
be kind of a cheating asshole and the later Tobias Menzies variant to be better
at not playing the field and toning down the arrogance. Since I knew Prince Philip only recently
died, whatever else happened on the show, he would not be having any fatal
accidents.
PP’s ancestry is half Greek, half German. To makes matters more bizarre, his sister was
a Nazi, and he grew up as a boy during the 1930s (S2/E9 Paterfamilias). When she died in a plane crash, he had to
attend her funeral in Nazi era Darmstadt, with all the pomp and arrogance the
ever-evil Nazis could muster. However,
unlike his uncle-in-law Edward VIII, young Prince Philip did not fall under the
spell of the Nazis and remained fairly normal.
Princess Margaret
(S1/2 Vanessa Kirby; S3/4 Helena Bonham Carter). Not in line to be Queen under any circumstances,
that should have freed her up to do as she pleased, but if there is ONE lesson “The
Crown” wants us to understand, it’s that the Royals have all sorts of seemingly
arbitrary restrictions on what they can and cannot do, yet not being in actual
control of the country don’t seem to enjoy nearly as many benefits as you would
imagine. In practice this worked out to
vetoing her relationship with Peter Townsend – confusingly, NOT the guitarist
for The Who – a dashing but married RAF officer. She had to settle for a cynical and bisexual
photographer, Lord Snowden (Ben Daniels), a relationship which crashed and
burned in the 1970s. In the first two
seasons she’s played by the relatively babacious Vanessa Kirby, and in season 3
abruptly morphs into Helena Bonham Carter, an actress who bears zero resemblance
to Kirby and is already well known in her own right.
Prince Charles (S3&4 Josh O’Connor). Up until season 3, he’s just a boy. There’s an episode where his schooling is at
issue, Prince Philip wanting to send him up to a gloomy school in the Scottish
highlands, Gordonstoun (S2/E9 Paterfamilias), where he himself went to school
as boy during the 1930s, kind of a boot camp atmosphere so dreary and depressing
that Prince Charles, as a father, made certain that his own boys William and
Harry did not have to suffer the same fate.
By season 3 he’s more grown up, and learns Welsh to take his investiture
in Wales, a part of Great Britain eager for some form of independence – at this
point played by Josh O’Connor (S3/E6 Tywysog Cymru).
The biggest issue with Charles is his difficult
relationship with Lady Diana (Emma Corrin) and Camilla Shand,
later Parker-Bowles (Emerald Fennell).
Here’s where some critics take issue with the narrative presented by the
show, claiming it pushes too much blame for the Charles-Diana issues on Charles
and overstates his ongoing relationship with CPB. What no one seems to deny is that Charles had
some prior romantic relationship with CPB and she was his clear favorite – had he
had his way, he would have married her and not Diana. Moreover, the show acknowledges that Diana herself
had a slew of lovers, and on the Australian tour could be extremely difficult
herself – e.g. insisting they bring William, still a baby, along on the trip with
them. Regardless of how much effort each
put into making the marriage work, it seems it was doomed from the start.
In fact, what with conspiracy theorist abundant everywhere
about almost anything, there are a few convenient accidents which somehow didn’t
occur. Margaret couldn’t marry Townsend
because his ex-wife was still alive. Wouldn’t
it have been convenient if that woman had an unfortunate accident? Likewise, CPB remained a distraction, even
after marrying Andrew Parker-Bowles – who himself was a part-time lover to
Princess Anne (!!!). If there was ever a
woman with an obvious target on her back, it was Camilla. As it is, she’s married to Charles
today. This is why conspiracy theories about the Royals being behind Diana's death in Paris in 1997 - after Charles and Diana had already divorced - are so implausible (as most conspiracy theories, by their nature, are).
Princess Anne. Of E2’s four children, the only girl. She seems very much like her aunt Margaret,
and of the four, the least spoiled and most realistic – at least as portrayed
in the series by Erin Doherty.
Lord Mountbatten. One of the more interesting characters in
Season 3 was Lord Mountbatten, played by none other than Game of Thrones archvillain
Charles “Tywin Lannister” Dance. Were it
not for the fact that Tywin Lannister was fully fleshed out in five novels before
HBO began the series, I might suspect that Tywin Lannister, as portrayed by Dance,
derives from Mountbatten. Of course the
reverse timing also throws this completely out of plausibility. More likely is that Dance simply channeled the
same arrogance and depth he brought to the Lannister role, to his portrayal of
Lord Mountbatten. Mountbatten is the
brother of Princess Alice, the mother of Prince Philip, i.e. Prince Philip’s
uncle.
Edward VIII (S2 Alex Jennings, S3 Derek
Jacobi). The controversial 10 month king. My father told me a lot about him, though I’m
not sure why. Maybe it was because he
(E8, not my father), and Wallis Simpson lived in the Bois de Boulogne, which
was close by to the US Embassy compound in Neuilly where we were living –
though we arrived there in 1979, seven years after E8 died. My own inclination would have been to cast Tim
Curry as E8.
By the way. As
noted, E8 did not have children. So far
as I understand, this means that if he had not abdicated in 1936 and remained
king, but died as he did in 1972, Queen Elizabeth would still become queen,
just in 1972 rather than 1952 – twenty years later. Well then – that’s a topic for another
alternate history novel….
Prime Ministers. As Season 4 ends, Margaret Thatcher has thoroughly
alienated everyone in Parliament and the general public as to lose her position
as Prime Minister. Again, critics claim
the show overstates her unpopularity, but no one can deny that, regardless of the
circumstances, Thatcher did leave office in 1990.
At the time of Queen Elizabeth’s coronation in 1952 the Prime
Minister was Winston Churchill, the famous wartime leader, played in the show
by John Lithgow. His successor was Anthony
Eden (Conservative) (1955-57) (played by Jeremy Northam), Harold MacMillan
(Conservative) (1957-63) (played by Anton Lessser), Harold Wilson (Labour)
(1964-1970) (played by Jason Watkins), Edward Heath (Conservative) (1970-74)
(played by Michael Maloney). Harold Wilson (Labour) (1974-1976), James Callaghan
(Labour) (1976-1979), and then Thatcher in 1979. As noted last week, this system of government
often results in prime ministers serving multiple nonconsecutive terms as the
parties’ relative fortunes at the polls and scandals push them in and out. In our own country, Grover Cleveland (1884-88
and 1892-96) enjoys the distinction of being the only president serving multiple
nonconsecutive terms. We’ll see if Trump
runs again in 2024. Down here in
Virginia, Terry MacAuliffe failed to win re-election – Virginia allows
governors to serve unlimited nonconsecutive terms. I’ve yet to see a pair of candidates rotate in
and out to take advantage of that.
The Queen took a policy of not publicly praising or criticizing
the Prime Minister. As a practical
matter, the show seems to indicate that her personal favorites were Churchill
and Harold Wilson. It seems to show her
as neutral towards Thatcher, with critics noting that the relationship was a bit
warmer than portrayed. Or it may be that
Thatcher’s portrayal by Anderson was a bit harsh – similar to complaints about
Prince Charles. Perhaps so, but in
neither case do the unfair portrayals work to improve the Queen’s image.
The US. Normally, the responsibility for dealing with
foreign countries rests with the Prime Minister. One exception is “The Commonwealth”, the
loose aggregate of the UK’s closely associated countries, mainly Canada, Australia,
New Zealand, South Africa, and numerous other former colonies which are now
independent, sovereign countries. Of
these, the United States is NOT part of the Commonwealth. We had a brief war in 1812-1815, the UK
remained neutral during our own Civil War (1861-65), alternate history novels
to the contrary notwithstanding, and we were on the same side in WWI (1914-18) and
WWII (1939-45). My own subjective
inclinations are to be highly favorable to all the English speaking countries,
especially our buddies to the north, Canada, the UK & Ireland, and
Australia/New Zealand. But hey – your mileage
may vary.
However, when it came time to sending troops to Vietnam in
1965, the Labour government under Harold Wilson was NOT cooperative in approving
of our adventure, much to the anger and resentment of US President Lyndon
Johnson, my mom’s former boss. SO when
the UK needed a bailout, LBJ (played by Clancy Brown) was very unsympathetic. It was left to Princess Margaret (S3/E2
Margaretology) to do what Harold Wilson and his Minions could not: charm LBJ into loosening the purse strings
and help out our buddies across the Atlantic – via exchanging naughty limericks
with LBJ, a somewhat earthy endeavor well out of the Queen’s comfort zone. FYI, only Australia sent troops to Vietnam to
help us out.
Game of Thrones. I’ve noticed a few Game of Thrones actors in
here. There’s a brief episode where the Queen,
who loves horses, visits Kentucky to research the state of the art in horsebreeding
and equine technology (S3/E4 Coup), and one of the characters is played by
Julian Glover, aka Maester Pycelle. I’ve
mentioned Charles Dance already, as Lord Mountbatten. And Prince Philip, in seasons 3 and 4, is
played by Tobias Menzies, better known to GOT fans as Edmure Tully.
Overall the show does a remarkable job of portraying not
only Queen Elizabeth II herself, as she grows into the role of Queen and all
the issues it involves, but also the royal family. As noted in my prior blog, for all their
wealth and prestige, living in castles and not having to hold down real jobs – apparently
the royalty is actually supported with taxes levied on ordinary UK taxpayers –
the royalty often have to deal with a whole range of serious restrictions on
their freedom which these same ordinary UK taxpayers don’t have to worry
about. Prince Charles and Princess
Margaret were both bludgeoned into unhappy marriages, and even the Queen had to
work at her own relationship with Prince Philip. On the other hand, with the PM exercising real
control over the country, the actual power wielded by the Queen and her family
is highly attenuated – to the point where their lives are rarely in any actual
danger. Lord Mountbatten’s death by an
IRA bomb on his boat seems to be the exception which proves the rule. Even the disgruntled, unemployed man, Fagan,
who broke into Buckingham Palace not once, but TWICE, only wanted to talk to the
Queen, as he was well aware that she was not directly responsible for his
misfortune; his local MP was Conservative and highly unsympathetic to his
plight.
Update 5/18/23:
Season 5. The narrative continues from 1991-1997. Cast changes aplenty: Imelda "Dolores Umbridge" Staunton as QE2, Jonathan "High Sparrow" (Game of Thrones) Pryce as Prince Philip, Dominic West (McNulty on "The Wire") takes over as Prince Charles, Elizabeth Debicki as Lady Diana, and Olivia Williams as Camilla Parker-Bowles. In addition we get Johnny Lee Miller (from "Trainspotting" and more recently playing Sherlock Holmes with Lucy Liu) as John Major, the PM who replaced Margaret Thatcher, and both Mohamed (father) and Dodi (son) Fayed entering the picture for Diana.
Here the narrative focuses on the drama between Charles and Diana, especially when Diana goes public with all her bitching about the royal family. West does a good job of making Charles more likable than he was in prior seasons. However, the narrative stops short of Diana's fatal crash in Paris, so I imagine that will come up in Season 6.
….