[Updated 4/23/21 – originally posted 6/10/11 after season 2]
I recently finished the eleventh and final season of this TV show
from ABC, I was very impressed and amused by the whole thing – from start to
finish. Amidst mediocre, lackluster and
dull programming half-heartedly offered to us as “entertainment”, there are
still remarkable gems to be found on the “idiot tube” for those with the
patience to look hard enough.
Premise. Three separate households, linked by a common
family bond.
Jay (Ed O’Neill), Gloria (Sofia Vergara) and their son Manny (Rico Rodriguez). Jay is an older guy (think Al Bundy with
marginally more charm) with his trophy Colombian wife Gloria and her son
Manny. Her ex-husband Javier (Benjamin
Bratt) is kind of a wild stallion who periodically shows up to make Jay uneasy
but ultimately shows that Jay, despite his age and conservative nature,
represents a stable father figure and provider which Gloria needs for herself
and Manny. For her part, Sofia Vergara
has to be, bar none, the hottest female actress on TV – Catherine Zeta-Jones
dialed up a few notches in hotness. She
is constant eye candy in every scene, even her accent is delicious. The show is worth watching for her alone. While there is some friction, and some
cross-cultural issues, this family mostly gets along pretty well, and Jay makes
an honest attempt to bond with Manny, not merely tolerate him as the baggage he
has to accept to sleep with Gloria.
Jay
and Gloria managed to have their own child Joe, who is still about 5 years old
when the show ends, but already shows an implausible degree of business sense,
practically a Ferengi. Gloria remains as
hot in season 11 as she was in season 2.
Phil (Ty Burrell), Claire (Julie Bowen, formerly Denise
Bauer on “Boston Legal”), and their children Haley (Sarah Hyland), Alex
(Ariel Winter), and Luke (Nolan
Gould). This is the standard family
unit. Claire is Jay’s daughter; Phil’s
father is played by Fred Willard. Haley
is the typical “hot but stupid” teen girl, Alex is the “smart but snotty and
fairly plain” (Daria) teen girl, and Luke is hopelessly stupid. For his part, Phil isn’t particularly bright
but has NO CLUE how clueless he really is as a father; he thinks he has all the
angles worked out but the results never support this assumption. He’s the typical real estate guy who’s overly
impressed with his own charm and wit, always cracking lame jokes (aka “dad
jokes”), a trait he clearly picked up from his father. He has some idiotic
fixation on doing magic tricks. Claire
is a decent mother but doesn’t always have all the answers herself, but at
least she doesn’t seem to assume she already knows it all, unlike Phil. Both of them give the appearance of muddling
through parenthood with only the vaguest of clues but all the best intentions.
After
being involved with various different men – one played by Nathan Fillion –
Haley returns to Dylan (Reid Ewing), the offbeat stoner type (though we never
see him smoke). They have twins. By the way, Gloria came on the scene, so to
speak, far too late to be Claire and Mitchell’s mother: she is Deedee, played
by Shelley Long, who we might remember from “Cheers”. Her character was a bit unhinged and killed
off at some point. By season 11 she’s
actually a tree (!).
Mitchell (Jesse Tyler
Ferguson), Cameron (Eric
Stonestreet) (gay couple) and their adopted Vietnamese baby girl, Lily. I found baby Lily to be amazingly cute. By
season 11 Lily has grown up to be an attractive teenage girl (Aubrey Anderson-Emmons),
though somewhat eye-rolling and snarky – not particularly likable. Mitchell is Jay’s son and Claire’s
sister. By now gays are sufficiently
positively portrayed on network TV that we can enjoy a flamboyantly ridiculous
depiction of this couple. On “Desperate
Housewives”, Bob plays the “normal” gay partner who could easily pass for
straight, while Lee is the “flamer” who embodies all the stereotypes. With Mitchell and Cameron, they BOTH
illustrate the stereotypes with hilarious regularity. I suppose they get away with it because
everyone else on the show is equally lampooned.
Even beautiful Gloria makes remarks about Colombians re: drug dealers,
murders, violence, etc. The fathers
attempt to do their best for her, but like the others, often fail as much
through sheer misadventure rather than incompetence (Phil) or indifference. Mitch and Claire seem to be from California,
while Cam is from a farm in Missouri and often makes farm jokes. By season 11 he’s been an assistant coach for
the high school football team and manages to snag the head coach job at a
university in Missouri. I actually
watched “Bad Teacher” (with Cameron Diaz) just to see Stonestreet play a straight
guy, though he only appears briefly as Diaz’ character’s grumpy and unfriendly
roommate.
The
show is filmed in the familiar “mockumentary” format where the characters
frequently talk directly to the audience (e.g. “The Office” and “Trailer Park
Boys”). They all share Michael Scott’s
tendency to make inadvertently negative revelations they believe are positive. The show is definitely a comedy and has as
much misadventure as any other – including “Two and a Half Men”, which had
previously been my standard for current TV quality. But as entertaining as Charlie Sheen and Jon
Cryer have been, Sofia Vergara is certainly much more enjoyable to watch.
From
season 3 to 11, Ariel Winter managed to….develop considerably, making her
competitive with Hyland, though still very much a nerd. Luke also grew up into a teenage boy. Almost all of the adult characters remain
essentially the same throughout the series.
I found the writing to also remain consistent in nature and quality with
no peak or “jumping the shark”, to borrow the Happy Days expression.